We may receive a commission if you sign up or purchase through links on this page. Here's more information.
Licensed Tax Attorneys & CPAs · A+ BBB Accredited · Free Consultation
I'm Logan Allec, CPA — I've reviewed dozens of tax-relief companies, and I founded my own to do it right. If you owe the IRS $10,000 or more, my team will review your case free and tell you exactly where you stand — no pressure, no obligation.
Get My Free Consultation →Free & confidential · Or call 866-8000-TAX
Disclosure: Choice Tax Relief is owned by Money Done Right founder Logan Allec, CPA.
-
Wall & Associates- Basics: Most tax relief companies are judged on customer complaints. Wall & Associates is judged on court records.
- Pros: Free 30-minute initial consultation.
- Cons: Trial findings in Minnesota and Virginia that the company misrepresented aspects of its services; Minnesota also found most clients there got no tax reduction and paid more in fees than they saved.
- FREE CONSULTATION:
Yes — free 30-minute initial consultation
- YEAR FOUNDED:
1992 (BBB record)
- BBB RATING:
C+ · pattern-of-complaints alert
- GUARANTEE:
Not published
Most tax relief companies are judged on customer complaints. Wall & Associates is judged on court records.
Two state attorneys general took it to trial and won. A Minnesota court found, in an October 11, 2024 order, that the defendants “knowingly and in bad faith deceived hundreds of Minnesotans.” A Virginia court found the company liable for misrepresenting its staff, its average results, and where its work would be performed. The Idaho Department of Finance imposed roughly $476,000 in penalties, restitution and costs, and the Idaho Supreme Court affirmed that on August 21, 2025. A separate New York class action was dismissed, and that dismissal was affirmed on appeal.
Disclosure: Money Done Right founder Logan Allec, CPA, owns Choice Tax Relief, which competes with the company reviewed here. That is exactly why the scorecard above is based on published, verifiable evidence rather than opinion.
- BBB Accredited: A+ Rating
- Owned by a CPA: Logan Allec, CPA
- Free Consultation: 100% Free, No Obligation
- Minimum Debt: Works with $10,000+
Table of Contents
Wall & Associates At a Glance
| Free Consultation | Yes — free 30-minute initial consultation |
| Fee Structure | Not published; regulators and customers describe an upfront retainer plus open-ended monthly fees |
| Money-Back Guarantee | Not published |
| BBB Rating | C+, not accredited; 5.0 stars from one review; active pattern-of-complaints alert |
| Year Founded | 1992 (BBB record) |
Who Wall & Associates Is
The legal entity is Wall & Associates, Inc. Its BBB profile lists a business start date of April 1, 1992; the company’s own website states no founding year and publishes a mailbox rather than a street address, PO Box 747, Marshall, Virginia 20116.
No owner or executive is named anywhere on that website. The names surface only in litigation: Ernest Kenneth Wall is identified as the owner and Patrick Mark Yates as the CEO, both individual defendants in the Minnesota case below.
Staff get one generic phrase: “Certified Public Accountants, Enrolled Agents, and/or tax practitioners.” Note the “and/or” — it commits to no particular credential on your case. No names, headcounts or license numbers are published.
The site claims “7 local offices covering all 51 states.” The United States has 50. It also states its services “are not available or offered to residents of the State of Idaho,” and claims to have cut client liabilities “by over $150 million dollars” — an unaudited claim about itself.
Services Offered
According to its website, Wall & Associates handles:
- Offer in compromise
- Tax liens and levies
- Wage garnishment relief
- Asset seizure resolution
- Unfiled returns
- Penalty abatement
- Installment agreements
- Trust-fund payroll tax matters
- State tax resolution
Two common IRS outcomes are not named on the site: Currently Not Collectible status and Innocent Spouse Relief. That doesn’t mean the firm won’t handle them, only that they aren’t listed — so ask. Currently Not Collectible is a standard IRS status worth asking any firm about if you genuinely cannot pay anything right now.
How Does Wall & Associates Work?
The company publishes little about its process. What follows comes from its site plus what regulators and courts documented.
Stage 1: The free consultation
The site offers a free 30-minute initial consultation. This is where you get quoted a number, because none exists in public anywhere. Ask for the person’s credential and license number and whether they will personally work your case: the Virginia court found the company liable for misrepresenting its staff as tax consultants, and Minnesota alleged the same.
Stage 2: The retainer
Engagement begins with an upfront payment. The Minnesota Attorney General alleged the company collected advance payments of up to $15,000 before delivering services. No retainer amount is published.
Stage 3: Monthly billing for the duration
Regulators and customers describe a monthly charge that then runs for as long as representation lasts. The Virginia Attorney General alleged in 2017 that fees “usually cost consumers hundreds of dollars per month” on top of upfront costs. With no published cap, endpoint or refund policy, the total cost is unknowable at signing.
Wall & Associates Cost
Nothing is published. No fee schedule, no dollar range, no minimum debt and no refund policy appears anywhere on the site — only an offer of “flexible payment arrangements with NO HIDDEN CHARGES,” with no numbers attached. You cannot comparison-shop a company that won’t publish a price.
Two independent sources of evidence agree on the structure:
- Regulators. The Virginia Attorney General alleged in 2017 that fees usually cost consumers hundreds of dollars per month on top of upfront costs. Minnesota alleged advance payments up to $15,000. The Idaho record documents fees from under $5,000 up to $98,000.
- Customers. ConsumerAffairs reviewers describe $2,500 to start and then $400 per month. A SuperMoney reviewer describes $2,500 up front and then $350 per month for over a year.
The documented pattern is a retainer roughly in the $2,500 to $5,000 range plus monthly fees of roughly $350 to $500, for the length of representation. That is not the company’s published price, because it has none. It is what regulators and customers describe.
Refund policy: not disclosed. Minimum debt: not disclosed. Before paying, get in writing what ends the monthly billing, what happens if you cancel in month three, and what resolution the firm will pursue.
Wall & Associates Complaints and Customer Reviews
The BBB figures are three separate metrics measuring three different things.
- Accreditation: the company is not BBB accredited.
- Letter rating: C+. A BBB letter grade is not a customer-satisfaction score. The BBB states that customer reviews are not used in calculating it, so the letter grade and the star rating are two separate measures of two different things. What makes the C+ notable here is not the grade itself but the alert that sits beside it.
- Active alert: “Pattern of Complaints,” live as of August 2026. The BBB’s rationale, verbatim: “Business has failed to resolve underlying cause(s) of a pattern of complaints.”
- Complaints closed in the last 3 years: 5. In the last 12 months: 0. Low in absolute terms.
- Star rating: 5.0 out of 5 — from exactly one published review, dated November 7, 2023. A sample size of one, not a satisfaction signal.
On ConsumerAffairs the company holds 3.5 out of 5 across 158 verified reviews, a real sample. Trustpilot, Google and Yelp could not be accessed for this review, so no rating is stated for them.
Reviewers who got a large reduction felt the fees were earned. From SuperMoney:
“Their help took my tax debt from $119,000 to just over $12,000. They earned their money.”
One customer’s outcome is not a prediction of yours. A Minnesota court found after trial that most of the company’s clients in that state received no tax reduction at all.
The negative theme is the fee structure, not service manners. From ConsumerAffairs:
“They charge $2500 to start with all these promises. And then $400 per month.”
That is the split. When the resolution is large the monthly billing looks like a fair price; when it isn’t, it is the whole experience.
Is Wall & Associates Legit?
It is a real business the BBB dates to 1992. The question is what courts and regulators concluded about how it sells and delivers its services. Here is what the searches surfaced.
Minnesota: a judgment after trial
State of Minnesota v. Wall & Associates, Inc., et al., Hennepin County District Court, Case No. 27-CV-18-19874, was filed December 11, 2018 against the company, Ernest Kenneth Wall and Patrick Mark Yates. The state alleged operating without required Minnesota registration; collecting advance payments up to $15,000 before delivering services; falsely advertising local Minnesota offices while using temporary rented space; falsely claiming typical settlement results; and presenting salespeople as “tax consultants.”
It did not settle. A bench trial produced a finalized adverse judgment. In an October 11, 2024 order the court found that the defendants “knowingly and in bad faith deceived hundreds of Minnesotans,” that most Minnesota clients received no tax reduction, and that clients typically paid more in fees than they saved. A permanent injunction was entered.
On April 15, 2025, Judge Francis J. Magill ordered $2,734,024.67 in restitution and $786,517.00 in civil penalties against Wall & Associates, Inc., a $415,500 penalty against Ernest Kenneth Wall and a $207,750 penalty against Patrick Mark Yates. The Minnesota Attorney General’s office characterized the combined judgment as “more than $4 million.”
Virginia: liable at trial, and the claims deadline has passed
The Virginia Attorney General sued on September 15, 2017 in Fauquier County Circuit Court under the Virginia Consumer Protection Act, alleging false claims that clients typically settle for around 10% of what they owe; misleading statements about case duration and monthly fees; misrepresentation of salespeople as “tax consultants” and “tax experts”; and temporary rented offices nationwide used to simulate a local presence.
At trial, the court found the company liable for misrepresenting its staff as tax consultants, misrepresenting average results and savings, and misrepresenting where services would be performed. It also identified the company as having operated as E. Kenneth Wall & Associates, Inc.; Mayfair Tax Help & Relief, Inc.; Mayfair Tax Help, Inc.; and Mayfair Tax, Inc. If your paperwork carries one of those names, it is the same company.
A national restitution claims portal for former customers, administered by Verus, LLC, was announced around August 7, 2025. The deadline to file was December 10, 2025, and it has passed. As of today, August 7, 2026, there is no open claims process to join. On August 7, 2025 the Tennessee Attorney General issued a notice directing Tennessee consumers to that same Virginia process, stating the company had collected more than a million dollars from hundreds of Tennessee consumers. That notice was not a separate Tennessee lawsuit.
Idaho: affirmed by the state supreme court
The Idaho Department of Finance alleged that the company acted as an unlicensed debt counselor under Idaho’s Collection Agency Act, contracting with 54 Idaho residents between 2011 and 2020 without the required license; falsely advertised a local Boise office that was temporary rented space; charged fees from under $5,000 up to $98,000; and continued operating after a 2012 department directive.
The penalties were $162,000 in civil penalties (54 violations at $3,000 each), $271,987.50 in fee restoration to 11 Idaho clients and $42,016.60 in department costs — roughly $476,000 total. The company appealed and lost at every level: an Ada County district judge affirmed on September 22, 2023, and the Idaho Supreme Court affirmed on August 21, 2025 (Docket No. 51310), holding that unpaid tax obligations are “debts” under the statute and rejecting the company’s federal-preemption argument. The matter is final, and its website now states it does not serve Idaho residents.
New York: a class action that was dismissed
Vandermast et al. v. Wall & Associates, Inc. was filed in Niagara County in April 2019 and removed to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York, Case No. 20-cv-736, alleging misrepresentation of the company’s nationwide office presence, presentation of salespeople as credentialed experts, and high-pressure sales tactics.
It was dismissed in October 2020, and the Second Circuit affirmed that dismissal in January 2022. The basis could not be determined from the public record, so this review does not describe it as a win on the merits or as a technicality. It was dismissed, the dismissal was affirmed, and the public record does not show on what basis.
What did not surface, and one piece of context
No FTC enforcement action surfaced in these searches — a statement about what the searches returned, not confirmation that none exists. And no public statement from Wall & Associates responding to the Minnesota, Virginia or Idaho outcomes could be located. That is not the same as declining to comment; it means none was found.
For context on the C+ rating: in 2016 Wall & Associates sued the Better Business Bureau of Central Virginia and others, alleging the BBB marketed its ratings as objective while applying subjective criteria. The district court dismissed the case and the Fourth Circuit affirmed on April 24, 2017, holding the complaint failed to show any consumer withheld business because of the rating.
Wall & Associates Pros and Cons
Pros
- Free 30-minute initial consultation.
- Long operating history — the BBB lists a start date of April 1, 1992.
- Broad service list covering the main IRS collection problems.
- 3.5 out of 5 on ConsumerAffairs from 158 verified reviews, a sample large enough to mean something.
- Only 5 BBB complaints closed in three years, none in the last twelve months.
Cons
- Trial findings in Minnesota and Virginia that the company misrepresented aspects of its services; Minnesota also found most clients there got no tax reduction and paid more in fees than they saved.
- Roughly $476,000 in Idaho penalties, restitution and costs, affirmed by the Idaho Supreme Court; the company no longer serves Idaho residents.
- No pricing, refund policy or guarantee published anywhere.
- No owner, executive or staff member named on its own website.
- Not BBB accredited, a C+ rating, and an active pattern-of-complaints alert; the 5.0 star rating comes from one review dated November 7, 2023.
- No public response to the Minnesota, Virginia or Idaho outcomes could be located.
Alternatives to Wall & Associates
Disclosure: Money Done Right founder Logan Allec, CPA, owns Choice Tax Relief, which competes with the company reviewed here. That is exactly why the scorecard above is based on published, verifiable evidence rather than opinion.
| Wall & Associates | 🏆OUR PICK🏆 Choice Tax Relief |
Optima Tax Relief | Community Tax | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
||||
| Free Consultation | Yes — free 30-minute initial consultation | Yes — length not published | Yes | Yes |
| Fee Structure | Not published; regulators and customers describe an upfront retainer plus open-ended monthly fees | Not published; publishes a $10,000 minimum debt, which the others do not | Two-stage: investigation fee, then resolution fee; amounts not published | Describes flat, fixed pricing; amounts not published |
| Money-Back Guarantee | Not published | None published | 15-day refund of the investigation fee only; fees for later phases are expressly excluded | No money-back terms published; a general satisfaction statement only |
| BBB Rating | C+, not accredited; 5.0 stars from one review; active pattern-of-complaints alert | A+, accredited 5/31/2022; separately 5 out of 5 from 1 customer review; 0 complaints on file | A+, accredited 6/18/2012; separately 4.07 out of 5 from 1,987 reviews; 788 complaints in three years | A+, accredited 7/1/2015; separately 4.21 out of 5 from 142 reviews; 35 complaints in three years |
Read the star ratings with their review counts attached — Choice’s 5 out of 5 rests on a single BBB review, Optima’s 4.07 rests on 1,987. Those are not comparable samples, and the complaint counts scale with client volume too.
Choice Tax Relief is owned by Logan Allec, CPA, founder of Money Done Right; it states that it is staffed by CPAs and tax attorneys and works with taxpayers who owe roughly $10,000 or more. We did not independently verify staff licensure at Choice, Optima or Community Tax for this review, so nothing in this table is a credential comparison.
Now notice what the table cannot tell you: not one of these companies publishes an actual price. The whole category hides its numbers until you are on a sales call, so the only things you can compare in advance are the guarantee terms and the enforcement record. Optima’s 15-day refund on the investigation fee is the only published money-back term of the four, and it expressly excludes everything billed after that phase. Wall & Associates is also the only one of the four whose enforcement record this review examined; the other three were not researched for legal history in this pass, so read the absence of that column as unexamined rather than clean. Our reviews of Optima, Community Tax and Choice Tax Relief run the same categories.
Who Wall & Associates Is Best For
On the published record we could not identify a taxpayer profile for whom this is the strongest available option. The narrow case for it: the firm has operated since 1992 per the BBB, handles the full range of IRS collection matters, and 158 ConsumerAffairs reviewers average it at 3.5 out of 5. Weigh that against what two trial courts found and what the Idaho Supreme Court affirmed.
Who Wall & Associates Is Not For
- Anyone who needs to know the price before signing. No published fee schedule, no published end to monthly billing.
- Idaho residents. The company’s own site states its services are not available or offered to them.
- Anyone on a tight or fixed budget. An open-ended monthly charge with no published cap is the riskiest structure in this industry.
- Anyone quoted a specific settlement percentage. The Virginia court found the company liable for misrepresenting average results and savings.
- Anyone who wants to know who is working their case. No staff are named and no license numbers published.
Final Thoughts
Most tax relief reviews weigh complaints against praise, because that is all the evidence there is. Not this one. Two trial courts found against this company, a third state’s supreme court affirmed roughly $476,000 in regulatory penalties against it, one class action was dismissed without the record showing why, and separately it publishes no price, no refund policy, no staff and no owner.
If you are about to sign, that is what you are weighing. If you are already mid-engagement, find the cancellation terms in your contract, request a written accounting of every dollar paid and every action taken on your case, and have an independent CPA, enrolled agent or tax attorney confirm where you actually stand with the IRS before you send another monthly payment. Outcomes in tax resolution depend entirely on your individual financial circumstances, and no firm can guarantee you a specific result.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is Wall & Associates a legitimate company?
- Did Wall & Associates lose in court?
- Can I still file a claim to get my money back?
- How much does Wall & Associates cost?
- Does Wall & Associates offer a money-back guarantee?
- What is Wall & Associates’ BBB rating?
- Does Wall & Associates work in every state?
- Who owns Wall & Associates?
Still deciding who to trust with your IRS debt?
Here's what I'd do: before you hire anyone, get a free case review from a licensed CPA. My team at Choice Tax Relief will tell you what your options actually are and what it should cost — even if you don't hire us.
Get My Free Case Review →For $10,000+ in IRS back taxes · Free & confidential · Or call 866-8000-TAX
Author:
Logan is a practicing CPA and founder of Choice Tax Relief and of course Money Done Right. After spending nearly a decade in the corporate world helping big businesses save money, he launched his blog with the goal of helping everyday Americans earn, save, and invest more money. Learn more about Logan.
Reviewer:
Logan is a practicing CPA and founder of Choice Tax Relief and of course Money Done Right. After spending nearly a decade in the corporate world helping big businesses save money, he launched his blog with the goal of helping everyday Americans earn, save, and invest more money. Learn more about Logan.
